1)  There is no evidence of any communication about the 7,500 offer leading up to or at any time following Oct 22, 2013.

2)  The 7,500 offer was never discussed at the November 4, 2013 meeting that Mast requested to discuss the McGuire case.  A witness at the meeting can confirm this.

3)  It is not possible to explain why Mast called the November 4th meeting to discuss the McGuire case with Dulberg if they already made an offer 4 weeks earlier and were waiting for Barch to reply at that time.


Barch made the 5,000 offer on November 18, 2013


4)  It is clear that Dulberg disagreed with the 5,000 offer from first hearing about it on Nov 18 until finally agreeing on December 24th.  The 7,500 offer was not mentioned once during these Mast-Dulberg exchanges.


5)  Dulberg quickly called for a meeting with Mast.  The 7,500 offer was not discussed at the November 20th meeting.  A witness at the meeting can confirm this.

6)  It is not possible to explain why Mast called the November 20th meeting or what was discussed if Dulberg already agreed to 7,500.